"Peter Pan Goes Wrong" - by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer & Henry Shields - Lyric Stage Company (Boston, MA.) - REVIEW

(Cover Photo: Members of the CAST of  "PETER PAN GOES WRONG" by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, now playing at Lyric Stage Company in Boston, MA. until December 31, 2026. Photo Courtesy Lyric Stage)

By Kevin T. Baldwin

METRMAG Reviewer

# 774-242-6724  

“...You shall tremble at the sight of Hook's impressive ars... [CUE CARD IS TURNED OVER] ...enal of weaponry."

                 - ("Dennis Tyde as Mr. Smee") /  Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer & Henry Shields

Lyric Stage Company

Presents the Uproarious

"PETER PAN GOES WRONG"


By Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer & Henry Shields

Directed by Paul Melone

Choreographer Ilyse Robbins°

Cast Includes: Kelby T. Akin* as “Robert,” Margaret Clark as “Annie (Fight Captain) ,” Nora Eschenheimer* as “Sandra,” Madeline Finkelman as “Gill (Dec 21 - Dec31) (Understudy Lucy/Gill) ,” Brit Garner as “Gill (Nov13 - Dec 20) ,” Gabriel Graetz* as “Francis (Understudy Chris/Robert) ,” Miki Grubic as “Understudy Dennis/Jonathan,” Jenine Florence Jacinto as “Lucy,” Chris Kandra as “Trevor,” David Keohane* as “Dennis,” John Kuntz* as “Chris,” Liam McCarron as “Understudy Max/Trevor/Francis,” Michelle Moran as “Understudy Annie/Sandra,” Marc Pierre* as “Max,”  Jon Vellante* as “Jonathan.”

Additional Creative Team:

Scenic Design - Erik D. Diaz**; Lighting Design - Kevin Dunn; Costume Design - E. Rosser; Sound Design and Composer - Alex Berg; Props Artisan - Lauren Corcuera; Wig Design - Kat Shanahan; Intimacy and Fight Director - Ted Hewlett°; Production Stage Manager - Polly Feliciano*; Assistant Stage Manager - Al Shea DiBiase*; Audio Supervisor - Joe Borsch; Automation Programmer - Evan Brown; Wardrobe Supervisor - Roisin Daly; Head Electrician - Gabe Goldman; Props Painter - Mack MacIntyre; Assistant Wardrobe Supervisor - Sunny Nordberg; Props Artisan - Ernest Shao; Run Crew - Ellen Efstathiou, Connor Hathaway, Lucas Musgrave.

* Member of Actors’ Equity Association, the Union of Professional Actors and Stage Managers in the United States

° Stage Directors and Choreographers Society

** Represented by United Scenic Artists, Local USA 829 of the IATSE

Performances:

November 13, 2026 through December 31, 2026 

(Contact Box Office for Exact Times) 

All performances to be held at LYRIC STAGE OF BOSTON, 140 Clarendon Street, Boston, MA. 02116

TICKETS:

Contact the Box Office at # 617-585-5678 or go to lyricstage.com

BUY TICKETS

COVID 19 PROTOCOLS

Contact Venue for Most Updated COVID-19 Safety Protocols and Information.

(Warning: The following review contains spoilers)

Lyric Stage Company  stumbles into the holidays with the riotous "PETER PAN GOES WRONG" another show from the "...GOES WRONG" franchise now playing in Boston. 

Written by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields of the Mischief Theatre Company, the show the third entry of the series which began in 2012 with the chaotically funny "THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG." 

The fictitious “Cornley Polytechnic Drama Society” has returned to Boston to offer their “unique” staging of the 1904 J.M. Barrie immortalized work, “Peter and Wendy.” 

Once the show gets underway, however, it is clear that their attempt to do the Barrie work justice just might require a pirate shipload of “pixiedust” to keep the author from spinning in his grave. 

Featuring the original fictional troupe from "THE PLAY THAT GOES WRONG" reprising their cast and crew characters, "PETER PAN GOES WRONG" made its London debut in 2013 before touring the UK in 2014 and running from 2015 through 2017 in the West End. 

After a stint in Canada, the show transferred to Broadway for a limited engagement in 2023. 

The Broadway production of "PETER PAN GOES WRONG" received award nominations from Outer Critics Circle, Drama Desk (winning for the category “Unique Theatrical Experience”) and Drama League, also winning a Broadway.com Audience Choice Award for Favorite New Play. 

The play was adapted into a one-hour BBC television special for Christmas 2016 with David Suchet serving as the narrator. 

Considered a farcical “play-within-a-play,” "PETER PAN GOES WRONG" follows the drama troupe once again epitomizing “Murphy’s Law.” 

The two-act show now playing at the Lyric Stage is chronically wrecked by the company’s amateurish efforts and interpersonal squabbles. 

The inherent charm of the "...GOES WRONG" series is that most theatre veterans in the audience, especially those experienced in community theatre, tend to laugh the loudest as they see so many recognizable or relatable foibles within each disastrous occurrence. 

Yeah - we've all been there.

Such is the case with the earnest effort of mounting "PETER PAN" by the folks of Cornley, which goes magnificently and horribly awry. 

The error-prone, accident-prone and inept-prone Cornley Drama Society (or Cornley Polytechnic Drama Society) tries once more to stage an “ambitious” (as in “foolhardy”), “high-flying” (as in “crash-and-burn”) production of J.M. Barrie's classic "PETER PAN." 

And of course, as you probably already gathered from the above that things…well, they just don’t go as planned. 

Intended as a family friendly fairytale story, things quickly devolve into a calamity-laden catastrophe of classic proportions. 

Just some of the chaos that ensues includes: 

The revolving set malfunctions, erratic lighting causes power outages, props are missing (with some that should never have been found), entrances missed (with some that should have been missed), and a multitude of mechanical rigging mishaps for supposedly “flying” characters. 

Actors and crew invariably end up injured, comatose, drugged up, suspended awkwardly mid-air, disrobed (unintentionally and unexpectedly), tangled in ropes, or simply crashing into scenery. 

Compounding things even further are internal cast and crew feuds and meltdowns. 

Beginning with the show’s director, Chris Bean (John Kuntz), who also plays “Mr. Darling” and “Captain Hook” - Chris must deal with his irksome assistant director, Robert (Kelby T. Akin) who also plays “Nana” the family dog, PETER PAN's “Shadow” and other characters. 

Both Kuntz and Akin are perfectly in tune with the frustrated directing duo that many times find themselves at odds with each other and their allegedly competent cast and crew. 

Robert must also content with his niece, Lucy (Jenine Florence Jacinto), who has paralyzing stage fright but has been given the role of “Tootles” and can barely breathe on stage. 

Jacinto, gifted at the more physical comedy and pratfalls required, gives a marvelously subdued performance that really comes to life toward the show’s calamitous conclusion. 

Managing (or mis-managing) things technically is Trevor Watson (Chris Kandra), "PETER PAN"'s head technician, whose only assistant is Gill (Brit Garner who plays the role from November 13th - December 20th and Madeline Finkelman from December 21st - December 31st), a technician and Emergency Medical Technician. 

"Why is there an EMT on set?" 

You wouldn’t ask that question if you had seen the Cornley Society’s prior work. 

Kandra has impeccable comedic timing throughout the show, highly necessary for proper execution (poor choice of wording, perhaps) of the show’s impending disasters and how Trevor must contend with each of them. 

As to the massive technical requirements by Lyric Stage Company to literally coordinate and mount this madness, the entire production under the direction of Paul Melone is outstanding.

The revolving set design for "PETER PAN GOES WRONG" takes up a good chunk of the Lyric Stage theatre space, but is absolutely astounding in how well it works to accommodate the amount of ridiculousness that unfolds.

It is definitely not an easy task to stage a show that features so much technical chaos and make it all look completely unplanned and random.

Yet the Lyric Stage cast and crew together ensure each and every chaotic moment is executed safely with accuracy and precise timing. 

(Photo: David Keohane as “Dennis,”  Nora Eschenheimer as “Sandra” and Marc Pierre as “Max” in a scene from  "PETER PAN GOES WRONG" by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields, now playing at Lyric Stage Company in Boston, MA. until December 31, 2026. Photo Courtesy Lyric Stage)

As the story continues, though, as mentioned, some of the chaos is far less technical and more personal in nature. 

The Society’s "PETER PAN" star, Jonathan (marvelously played by Jon Vellante) is an egomaniacal horndog who has the hots for lead actress Sandra (Nora Eschenheimer), who plays “Wendy Darling.” 

Wendy is unaware that Jonathan is also having a fling (or flinging around) with Annie (Margaret Clark), who plays multiple characters including “Liza,” “Mrs. Darling,” “Tinker Bell” among others. 

Clark is extremely versatile as Annie who has to contend with multiple rapid-speed costume changes all while managing multiple characters throughout the production. 

Eschenheimer is equally dynamic as the undeterred Sandra who is determined to survive playing Wendy in this production even if it kills her...and it just might. 

The above actors involved in this tawdry backstage triumvirate cause headaches (among other injuries) for co-stars Max Bennett (Marc Pierre), who plays “Michael Darling” (and later a costumed “Crocodile”), and Dennis Tyde (David Keohane), who plays “John Darling” (and later a costumed “Smee”). 

Keohane as Dennis is truly on point rendering quite possibly the show’s funniest character – that actor who cannot recall ANY lines without prompting by use of a headset or cue cards. 

Meanwhile, Marc Pierre as Max provides us with a “Charlie Brown” equivalent, expertly playing a character that is sensitive, gets absolutely no respect from others and is victim of unrequited love for another in the show. 

Rounding out the Cornley cast is Francis Beaumont (Gabriel Graetz), who also plays the amiable “Narrator” and pirate “Cecco.” 

As was the case in its originating show, the "...GOES WRONG" chaos repeatedly trips off the stage and into the house, with actors ad-libbing or pulling audience members into the mayhem. 

Compounding the chaos many have come to expect from the "...GOES WRONG" series, the Cornley actors are interrupted and break character as recorded sound effects unexpectedly airs excruciatingly personal revelations. 

What may take some by surprise, though, is that, unlike the original "...GOES WRONG" show, there is also an unexpected sweetness that comes with "PETER PAN GOES WRONG." 

It is even, at times, inspiring as we watch how, in spite of the increasing technical calamities along with wounds both physical and emotional, the troupe stubbornly – if perhaps foolishly and unadvisedly - persists. 

That’s the determined, joyous and unbreakable (at least in theory) spirit of theatre folk for you.

"PETER PAN GOES WRONG" by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields continues in Boston until December 31st and is a zany holiday delight from Lyric Stage Company.  

Coming up next at Lyric Stage Company will be Rachel Wagstaff's stage adaptation of Agatha Christie's mystery "THE MIRROR CRACK'D" running from February 5th, 2027 through February 28th, 2027.

For more information and tickets, contact the Lyric Stage Company Box Office at # 617-585-5678 or go to lyricstage.com.

BUY TICKETS

Approximately two hours with one intermission.

Kevin T. Baldwin is a member of the American Theatre Critics Association (ATCA)

@MetrmagReviews

@Theatre_Critics

ABOUT THE SHOW

The Cornley University Drama Society is at it again. 

Chaos unfolds as a troupe of inept actors boldly takes on the ambitious staging of J.M. Barrie’s "Peter and Wendy." 

A wardrobe malfunction or two, a series of harrowing falls, some flubbed lines, and an epic meltdown courtesy of Captain Hook himself turn the play upside down. 

Throw in a love triangle, a tormented narrator, and blunders around every corner, and it's a frenzied comedic battle to the finish. 

From the creators of "The Play That Goes Wrong," this is one trip to Neverland that is as hilarious as it is disastrous. 

Fun for the whole family.

ABOUT THE LYRIC STAGE OF BOSTON

Founded in 1974 and in residence at 140 Clarendon Street since 1991, THE LYRIC STAGE OF BOSTON is Boston’s oldest resident theatre company. Our mission is to produce and present live theatre in Greater Boston with an intimate approach that promotes inclusivity and connection. THE LYRIC STAGE leads an effort to integrate live theater and theater education into the lives of all residents of greater Boston.

LYRIC STAGE OF BOSTON

140 Clarendon Street

Boston, MA. 02116

# 617-585-5678

www.lyricstage.com