
(Cover Photo: Ken Golner as "Gordon" and the CAST of the musical "A NEW BRAIN" by William Finn and James Lapine from Nashoba Players in Westford, MA. through November 21, 2026. Photo Credit: Robert Mattson)
By Kevin T. Baldwin
METRMAG Reviewer
# 774-242-6724
“I’m where your kindness begins...”
- ("Lisa") / William Finn and James Lapine

Music and Lyrics by William Finn
Book by William Finn and James Lapine
Directed and Choreographed by Melissa Lynch
Music Director Kathryn Denney
Producer Amy Newberg
Cast Includes: Ken Golner as “Gordon Michael Schwinn,” Carolyn Schneyer as “Mimi Schwinn,” David Sowerbutts as “Roger Delli-Bovi,” Heather Pruiksma as “Rhoda,” Pamela Petterchak as “Mr. Bungee,” Shelby Blakey as “Rikki,” Leeta White as “Lisa,” Joel Hersh as “Dr. Jafar Berensteiner,” Jennifer Shotkin as “The Minister,” Elizabeth Dreifus as “Waitress/Nancy D.”
Additional Creative Team:
Production Manager - Rich Moore; Stage Manager - Casey Manseau; Lighting Designer - Matt Valeri; Sound Designer - Chris Cooper; Props Coordinator - Deede Bergeron; House Manager - Amy Newberg.
Performances:
November 13, 2026 through November 21, 2026
(Contact Box Office for Exact Times)
Parish Center for the Arts, 10 Lincoln St, Westford, MA. 01886
TICKETS:
For tickets and more information visit https://nashobaplayers.org/shows/current/intro/
COVID 19 PROTOCOLS Contact Venue for Most Updated COVID-19 Safety Protocols and Information.
(Warning: The following review contains spoilers)
Just in time for a much-needed post-Midterm Election Thanksgiving, Nashoba Players presents the whimsical musical "A NEW BRAIN," now playing in Westford.
Featuring music and lyrics by William Finn and a book by Finn and James Lapine, the show draws inspiration from an autobiographical event for Finn.
"A NEW BRAIN" deals directly with Finn’s own health crisis from a diagnosed “arteriovenous malformation and the healing power of art” requiring surgery.
The protagonist of the musical represents Finn himself, with the character fearing he may not survive, becoming obsessed over what will ultimately be his musical legacy, or perhaps, if he will have any musical legacy.
Mostly sung through but hardly operatic, "A NEW BRAIN" started as a series of songs that Finn wrote after being hospitalized.
An argument could be made that the songs would have made for a better musical revue than story because some of the songs seem disconnected from the thread of the character’s required surgery.
The musical made its Off-Broadway debut in 1998 and has since been revived multiple times in the U.S. and abroad.
After its first workshop in 1996, Lapine became involved with the show which resulted in another workshop in 1997.
As "A NEW BRAIN" advanced to Off-Broadway for a limited run in 1998, where it only lasted 116 performances.
Yet, among that cast was burgeoning Broadway icon Kristin Chenoweth, who received early praise in Playbill which proclaimed "it's unlikely anyone will equal Kristin Chenoweth in the role of 'Nancy D., the waitress.’”
While "A NEW BRAIN" was neither a critic’s darling nor did boffo box office, it did go on to win the 1999 Outer Critics Circle Award for Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical and received two 1999 Drama Desk Award nominations, for Outstanding New Musical and Outstanding Music.

(Photo: Leeta White as “Lisa” in a moment from the musical "A NEW BRAIN" by William Finn and James Lapine from Nashoba Players in Westford, MA. through November 21, 2026. Photo Credit: Robert Mattson)
As the Nashoba Players' production begins, appearing throughout the show is Lisa (Leeta White), a homeless woman, who solicits the audience for “change.”
White does quite well in the role, serving not as a narrator nor a guide but rather as a one-woman Greek chorus, stepping in and out of the action, and being a singing proponent of "Change."
Through Lisa, the concept of "change" is significant in that she literally requires actual coinage to survive, but the protagonist hits a crossroads, needing a deep, metaphorical change as part of an ongoing personal evolution and shifting perspective.
"Change" is also quite possibly where William Finn himself is asking us to consider changing in how we all treat one another.
Songwriter Gordon Michael Schwinn (Ken Golner) works at his piano to meet a deadline for a song for a children's television show hosted by “Mr. Bungee” (Pamela Petterchak), a flamboyant, life-sized frog (no - you read that right).
The song he is working on is “Frogs Have So Much Spring (aka “The Spring Song”),” but he realizes he is experiencing writer’s block because he absolutely hates his job.
So, Gordon takes a break from writing to go to a restaurant to meet his best friend and agent Rhoda (Heather Pruiksma), who presses Gordon to keep writing the song.
Pruiksma is quite impressive as Gordon’s demanding and driven agent, but who is also deeply caring and wants the best for Gordon.
As a waitress at the restaurant (Elizabeth Dreifus) recounts the daily specials at the restaurant in the song “Calamari,” Gordon passes out, prompting Rhoda and the waitress to initiate a "911 Emergency" call to take Gordon to the hospital.

(Photo: Ken Golner as "Gordon" and the CAST of the musical "A NEW BRAIN" by William Finn and James Lapine from Nashoba Players in Westford, MA. through November 21, 2026. Photo Credit: Robert Mattson)
At the hospital, in a flurry of activity between the hospital’s medical staff, Gordon recounts his greatest fear, which is dying before realizing his full musical potential in "I Have So Many Songs" which flows into the full company number "Heart and Music."
The above is really where the quirky Nashoba Players' musical takes off and is where it succeeds most, as it brings in multiple characters that will impact on both Gordon’s mental and spiritual odyssey that follows.
As we learn in the song "Trouble in His Brain," a neurosurgeon, Dr. Jafar Berensteiner (Joel Hersh), explains that an MRI will be required to diagnose Gordon’s condition.
Gordon is also visited by a minister (Jennifer Shotkin), who tries to impose Protestant beliefs on Gordon, who is Jewish.
Both Hersh and Shotkin do well in their supporting roles, but their characters appear only briefly and aren’t really flushed out as well as other characters closer to Gordon.
Two nurses, Nancy D., aka "the thin nurse" (Elizabeth Dreifus), and Rikki, aka "the nice nurse" (Shelby Blakey) request a family history from Gordon.
Similar to Hersh and Shotkin, both Dreifus and Blakey do a fine job as the contrasting nurses that continuously elevate both Gordon’s head and blood pressure - but otherwise their backstories feel slightly lacking.
In fact, many of the characters we meet feel less fully formed to truly impact the story and more like an afterthought – some “thing” required just to establish where Gordon is rather than us learning about more of who they are to Gordon.
Gordon begins to see a recurring hallucination of “Mr. Bungee” who criticizes Gordon at every possible opportunity.
Petterchak is fun to watch as Bungee who becomes less and less likable as Gordon’s condition deteriorates and his hallucinations become more aggressive.
Gordon's mother, Mimi (Carolyn Schneyer), tries to reassure Gordon and herself that everything will be alright in the song "Mother's Gonna Make Things Fine."
Schneyer is wonderful as the stereotypical worried mother, fiercely devoted to her son while not quite understanding of her son’s life choices.
Yet, even when Gordon’s medical crisis is completely out of her control, Mimi tries to be there for him in the worst possible way…and it is the worst possible way.
Gordon awaits his boyfriend, Roger (David Sowerbutts), who sings about his true passion in "Sailing" (a song which re-uses the word more times than Christopher Cross EVER did on his song of the same name).
Sowerbutts has a simply gorgeous singing voice and the chemistry and affection displayed between Gordon and Roger comes across as completely genuine.

(Photo: David Sowerbutts as “Roger Delli-Bovi” in a moment from the musical "A NEW BRAIN" by William Finn and James Lapine from Nashoba Players in Westford, MA. through November 21, 2026. Photo Credit: Robert Mattson)
The best numbers in the musical come thanks to the efforts of the entire company executing the choreography provided by Melissa Lynch, who also directed.
The first musical high point occurs as Gordon claims he has only inherited the worst traits of his parents in the song "Gordo's Law of Genetics.”
The next comes in a big MRI scene, as Gordon contends with his claustrophobia and imagines he is on a sailing trip with Roger in the number "Sitting Becalmed in the Lee of Cuttyhunk," quite possibly the best number in the musical.
Another funny group moment comes as we learn more about Gordon’s life when he recalls feeling abandoned due to his father's horse betting and his parents' eventual divorce in the number, "And They're Off.”
Advising of the results of the MRI, Dr. Berensteiner informs Gordon that he has an arteriovenous malformation which will require a "Craniotomy."
If successful, all will be well (apart from any of those pesky normal side-effects from the temporary partial removal of a human skull), but, if not, Gordon could either suffer massive brain damage or die.
Gordon sends his new song to Mr. Bungee, who hates it, storming off to have his son write the song "Yes.”
While "A NEW BRAIN" originally was presented in a single act, the Nashoba production presents it in two acts, with the second act focusing more on the day of Gordon’s surgery.
In a coma, Gordon hallucinates about those in his life taking part in a surreal mini-opera consisting of chapter songs "Brain Dead," "Whenever I Dream," "Eating Myself Up Alive," "The Music Still Plays On," and concluding with a friendly Mr. Bungee telling Gordon to wake up in "Don't Give In" leading Gordon back to consciousness.

(Photo: Ken Golner as "Gordon" and the CAST of the musical "A NEW BRAIN" by William Finn and James Lapine from Nashoba Players in Westford, MA. through November 21, 2026. Photo Credit: Robert Mattson)
Even with a minimalist set design, some of the Nashoba show’s scene transitions are not quite seamless, with some of the set redressing sometimes haggard.
Also, there are some noticeable anachronisms given the show is supposedly set in the "early 1990s," such as the usage of more advanced cellphone technology and a vertical MRI chamber (both of which did not happen more widespread until closer to the end of the decade).*
(*Note: To be fair, these items were also used in the 2015 Broadway Encores' revival of the show - so the timeframe in which the story originally took place may have adjusted over the years.)
The musical’s idiosyncratic libretto comes with its shares of highs and lows but overall, the dedicated ensemble gives its best effort, and the highs far outnumber the lows.
Golner’s performance as Gordon pulls everything together, with the Gordon character serving almost as an “outsider” - reactive to all the absurdity in and around his career and life as both now potentially face “termination.”
Golner’s portrayal of that reactiveness to the eccentricities executed by an enthusiastic ensemble is what ultimately makes "A NEW BRAIN" work and, because it is all way too much fun to watch, any of the above minor issues are quickly forgiven.
The accompaniment by the Nashoba musicians under the leadership of Music Director Kathryn Denney is especially outstanding.
"A NEW BRAIN" continues from Nashoba Players in Westford, MA. until November 21st, 2027 and catching this show before it leaves should be a no-brainer.
Coming up next for Nashoba Players will be the Matt Cox show “PUFFS” which will run from April 23rd through May 1st, 2027.
Tickets are available online at: https://nashobaplayers.org/shows/current/intro/
Approximately two hours with one intermission.
Kevin T. Baldwin is a member of the American Theatre Critics Association (ATCA)
@MetrmagReviews
@Theatre_Critics


ABOUT THE SHOW
Winner of the 1999 Outer Critics Circle Award for Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical!
Based on the real-life experience of composer William Finn (whose other shows include "Falsettos" and "The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee," "A NEW BRAIN" follows Gordon, a struggling composer, whose life is turned upside down by the diagnosis of a brain tumor.
Surrounded by his partner, mother, co-worker, and an eccentric medical team, Gordon drifts in and out of consciousness while trying to finish songs for a children’s television show featuring "Mr. Bungee" - a character who begins to infiltrate his medical nightmare.
As he faces mortality, Gordon is forced to confront his relationships, his career, and ultimately the healing power of art.

ABOUT THE NASHOBA PLAYERS
NASHOBA PLAYERS is a dynamic, non-profit community theatre that has been dedicated to providing cultural enrichment through live theatre in drama, musicals and comedy to Westford and surrounding communities. THE NASHOBA PLAYERS home stage is at the Parish Center for the Arts at 10 Lincoln Street in Westford, MA. It is an intimate and inviting venue where THE NASHOBA PLAYERS offers cabaret seating for shows. Each season offers three or more performances which include drama, comedy, musicals, and sometimes a whimsical tongue-in-cheek melodrama or an elegant dinner theatre experience.
10 LINCOLN STREET
WESTFORD, MA. 01886